IIl Siciliano Ristorante Italiano

Il Siciliano Ristorante Italiano

8.7

1118 Myrtle Ave, Enumclaw, WA 98022, USA

Visit website

Thursday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM

Restaurant · $$ · Beer, wine and cocktails · 1,478 Google ratings

Rate this spot on Google

A menu featuring an array of classic Italian dishes, specializing in pizza, in a relaxed setting. A family-friendly pick in Enumclaw.

Kids menuGood for kids

Photos

Il Siciliano Ristorante Italiano in Enumclaw
Photo: Il Siciliano Ristorante Italiano · Google
Il Siciliano Ristorante Italiano in Enumclaw
Photo: Il Siciliano Ristorante Italiano · Google
Il Siciliano Ristorante Italiano in Enumclaw
Photo: Dave Pierce · Google

Ratings

Kids8.7
Food8.4
Drinks8.4
Vibes8.7

Reviews (5) from Google

The Mt Rainier of Italian restaurants. Other mountains hope to be Rainier but they can’t be. Each of our meals were EXCELLENT. Each employee was EXCELLENT. The speed of service was EXCELLENT. 10/10 would come back.

@Shut Up and Dill10.0/10 2026-08-03

Apparently they forgot to make a pizza that one of us ordered, so they put the rest of our group's food under a heat lamp for 15', waiting for the pizza to be baked. Our dishes were barely warm. That's a lot of money to pay for food that isn't hot and fresh. Very disappointed. Good service and nice atmosphere though.

@Gentry Stretz6.0/10 2026-06-22

Always wonderful and friendly service, relaxing rustic vibe and super flavorful food. Everything from the oil to the dessert (housemade tiramisu) was so flavorful, hot and savory. This place never disappoints.

@Jm Perez8.0/10 2025-05-28

First off, our waitress Carly was amazing, she was kind and attentive and did a wonderful job. The food, is very mediocre. I got the pasta puttanesca, which was bland, noodles felt like they came from a box. Everyone else at my table was unimpressed by the food. There was also an awkward experience where one of our party had forgotten their ID after we were sat in the bar and the staff (other than Carley) made us feel awkward and handled the situation poorly. We will likely not be returning.

@Callie B4.0/10 2026-08-31

I recently visited Applebee's in Bonney Lake for dinner with my wife and brother, and we had a fantastic experience. The food was excellent, and the service was top-notch, creating a great vibe throughout our meal. The pizza was particularly delicious—fresh and full of flavor. It was definitely worth every penny spent. We’ll be coming back again!

@Saurabh Singh Negi8.0/10 2024-09-26